He was named to the All-CCHA Rookie Team, All-CCHA First Team, AHCA West First-Team All-American, AHL All-Rookie Team, and AHL Second All-Star Team. In the NHL Boyle won a Stanley Cup championship in 2004 with the Tampa Bay Lightning. He was named to the NHL Second All-Star Team twice. Boyle has represented Canada in international competition winning a Gold medal at the 2010 Winter Olympics and a Silver at the 2005 World Championships. He signed a two year deal with the New York Rangers in July 2014.